First vs Second Mortgage Private Loans: How Ranking Changes Price and Risk
ADS Team
Author
November 14, 2026
1 day ago
17
views

In short: A first mortgage is repaid first from the proceeds of an enforced sale; a second mortgage is repaid only from what is left. That ranking is why second mortgage private loans cost more: the second lender absorbs losses first, needs the first lender's consent and controls less of any enforcement. In the worked waterfall below, the first lender is covered even if the property sells 43% below value, and the second only if it sells no more than about 20% below.
Key takeaways
- On enforcement, sale costs come off the top, then the first mortgage is paid, then the second, then the owner.
- In the example, the first lender can absorb a 43% fall in the sale price; the second can absorb about 20%.
- That position, plus consent, a capped priority and less control of enforcement, is why second-ranking money is priced higher.
- Second lenders look at total LVR across both loans, and some use the first lender's priority amount rather than its balance.
- Keeping a bank first and adding a private second usually costs less than one large private first: $13,500 a year less in the example.
- One private first makes sense when the bank will not consent, is enforcing, or the structure needs one lender in control.
What does ranking mean for a private loan?
When more than one lender holds security over the same property, the order in which they are repaid matters more than anything else in the loan. Registered mortgages generally rank in the order they are registered, unless the lenders agree otherwise in a deed of priority. The first-ranking lender is repaid in full from the proceeds of a sale before the second-ranking lender receives anything, and so on down the line, with the owner last.
Ranking also decides control. The first mortgagee decides when and how to enforce. A second mortgagee generally has a power of sale too, but any sale is subject to the first mortgage, so in practice it has to deal with the first lender, or repay it, to take control. A caveat sits lower again: Moneysmart describes a caveat as a legal notice that shows who has an interest in your property, and a caveat lodged behind a registered mortgage generally ranks behind it, with weaker enforcement rights than a registered second mortgage.
Worked example: who gets paid when the property is sold?
For illustration, a commercial property is worth $1,500,000. A bank holds a first mortgage of $750,000 (50% LVR) and a private lender holds a second mortgage of $300,000, taking total debt to $1,050,000 (70%). The borrower defaults and the property is sold. By then the payout figures have grown:
- First mortgage: $750,000 plus $40,000 of default interest and costs = $790,000
- Second mortgage: $300,000 plus $36,000 of default interest and $20,000 of costs = $356,000
- Costs of sale (agent, legal, marketing, holding): $60,000
| Sold 10% below value | Sold 25% below | Sold 35% below | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | $1,350,000 | $1,125,000 | $975,000 |
| Less costs of sale | -$60,000 | -$60,000 | -$60,000 |
| Available to lenders | $1,290,000 | $1,065,000 | $915,000 |
| First mortgage receives | $790,000 | $790,000 | $790,000 |
| Second mortgage receives | $356,000 | $275,000 | $125,000 |
| Second lender's recovery | 100% | 77.2% | 35.1% |
| Owner receives | $144,000 | Nil | Nil |
The bank is repaid in full in all three cases. The private second lender is repaid in full only in the first, and loses $81,000 in the second case and $231,000 in the third. The owner loses everything once the sale price falls far enough for the second lender to take a loss.
How much of a fall can each lender absorb?
Work out the sale price at which each lender is exactly repaid:
- First mortgage: $790,000 + $60,000 of sale costs = $850,000. That is $650,000, or 43.3%, below the $1,500,000 value.
- Second mortgage: $790,000 + $356,000 + $60,000 = $1,206,000. That is $294,000, or 19.6%, below value.
The two lenders are exposed to the same property and the same borrower, yet the second loan has less than half the protection of the first. In credit risk terms, its loss given default is far higher for the same probability of default, and loss given default is one of the three numbers that set a loan's price; see PD, LGD and EAD: the three numbers that price your loan. The cushion also shrinks as default interest and costs accrue, because every dollar added to the first lender's payout comes straight off the second lender's recovery.
Why does second-ranking money cost more?
| Factor | First-ranking private loan | Second-ranking private loan |
|---|---|---|
| Loss absorption | Losses reach it only after the second is wiped out | Takes the first loss after the owner's equity |
| Control of enforcement | Decides timing and method | Must deal with, or repay, the first lender |
| Consent | Not needed | Usually needs the first lender's consent and a deed of priority |
| Monitoring | Its own loan only | Has to watch arrears on a loan it does not control, and may pay them to protect its position |
| Size | Often larger | Often smaller, with similar fixed legal and valuation costs |
| Pricing (indicative) | Lower rate and fees for a similar LVR | Commonly several percentage points higher, varying by lender and total LVR |
Each lender sets its own pricing, and both sit above bank rates, which move with the RBA's cash rate target (4.60% from 30 September 2026; check the current figure). For the consent process, see second mortgages: consent, priority and bad credit.
How do lenders look at total LVR?
A second lender's own loan may be small, but it lends against the total debt on the property. In the example, $750,000 plus $300,000 on a $1,500,000 property is a total LVR of 70%.
The deed of priority can change that figure. If the bank's priority amount is set at $850,000, to allow for a limit above the current $750,000 balance plus interest and costs, a careful second lender counts $850,000 + $300,000 = $1,150,000, a total LVR of about 76.7%. The higher the first lender's priority amount, the less room there is behind it. When you negotiate the deed, ask for a priority amount close to the bank's actual limit.
Total LVR caps for second mortgages vary by lender and property type, and are lower for commercial, rural or vacant property than for a house in a capital city (indicative). Try different structures with the bridging finance calculator, and see LVR and equity calculations for the arithmetic.
Keep the bank first and add a second, or refinance into one private first?
For illustration, the owner in the example needs $300,000 more. Two structures (example rates, not offers):
| A: bank first plus private second | B: one private first mortgage | |
|---|---|---|
| Loans | $750,000 at 7% + $300,000 at 13% | $1,050,000 at 10% |
| Annual interest | $52,500 + $39,000 = $91,500 | $105,000 |
| Blended rate | 8.71% | 10% |
| Establishment fee at 2% | $6,000 (on the second only) | $21,000 |
Structure A costs $13,500 a year less in interest and $15,000 less in establishment fees, because only the second portion pays private rates. That is why, where the bank will consent, keeping it in first position is usually the cheaper route.
Structure B makes sense when A is not available or not safe: the bank refuses consent; the bank loan is in arrears or already being enforced; it is maturing or in breach of covenants; the plan needs one lender in control (for example, a property heading for sale or redevelopment); or a fixed bank rate is not an issue because the bank loan is variable. Ask about break costs on any fixed bank loan before choosing B.
What changes when the borrower is a company?
Many business-purpose private loans are made to companies, with the property mortgage backed by a general security agreement over the company's other assets and personal guarantees from the directors. Two extra layers of ranking then apply.
- Personal property. Security over assets other than land, such as equipment, stock and receivables, has its own priority rules under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009, with registration on the PPSR central to them. A second lender behind a bank may also rank behind the bank's general security.
- Insolvency. ASIC's guide for creditors on liquidation explains that a secured creditor can appoint a receiver to realise its secured assets, that this right continues after the company goes into liquidation, and that it can claim in the liquidation for any shortfall. A second-ranking lender's shortfall becomes an unsecured claim, which is another reason it prices the position higher.
Mezzanine finance in a development works the same way: a second-ranking lender behind a senior construction lender, under an agreement that sets out who controls enforcement. See mezzanine and second mortgage finance.
What are the common mistakes, and what should you do next?
- Comparing a second mortgage's rate with a first mortgage's rate as if the risk were the same.
- Agreeing a deed of priority with a priority amount far above the bank's actual limit.
- Refinancing a cheap bank first into a private first when consent was available.
- Ignoring how default interest on the first loan erodes the equity behind it.
- Forgetting that directors' guarantees make the shortfall personal.
Work out your total LVR, the priority amount, and the cost of both structures before you choose. When you know which one you need, post one private loan request on ADS, stating the ranking you are asking for, and 200+ verified lenders and brokers can ask about it.
Frequently asked questions
Who gets paid first when a mortgaged property is sold?
After the costs of sale, the first-ranking mortgagee is paid its full payout figure, then the second, then any later-ranking interests, and the owner receives anything left. A deed of priority can change the order or cap the amount a lender ranks ahead for. In the worked example the second lender recovers in full at a 10% lower price, but only 35.1% at a 35% lower price.
Why are second mortgage rates higher?
Because the second lender absorbs losses first, controls less of any enforcement, usually needs the first lender's consent and has to monitor a loan it does not control. In the example the first lender is covered until the sale price falls 43%, and the second only until it falls about 20%. Lenders price that difference.
Can a second mortgagee sell the property?
Generally a second mortgagee has a power of sale too, but any sale is subject to the first mortgage, so in practice the first mortgage has to be repaid from the proceeds or by the second lender. That is one reason second lenders watch the first loan closely. Get legal advice on your own documents.
Is one private loan cheaper than a bank loan plus a second mortgage?
Usually not, because with a bank first only the smaller second portion pays private rates. In the example, $750,000 at 7% plus $300,000 at 13% costs $91,500 a year, against $105,000 for one $1,050,000 private loan at 10%. One private loan can still make sense if the bank will not consent or is enforcing.
What is total LVR?
Total LVR is all the debt secured on a property, first and second together, divided by its value. Second lenders lend against it, and some use the first lender's priority amount instead of its balance. In the example, a $750,000 first and a $300,000 second on a $1,500,000 property give a total LVR of 70%.
Does a caveat rank behind a registered mortgage?
A caveat lodged after a registered mortgage generally ranks behind it. A caveat notifies an interest and stops later dealings being registered without the caveator's consent, but it does not give the same enforcement rights as a registered mortgage. That is part of why caveat lending usually costs more than a registered second mortgage. The details vary by state.
Related reading
- Second Mortgages: Consent, Priority and Bad Credit
- Mezzanine and Second Mortgage Finance
- Caveat Loan vs Second Mortgage: Which Do You Need?
Sources
- Caveat (glossary definition) — ASIC Moneysmart
- Cash rate target — Reserve Bank of Australia
- Personal Property Securities Act 2009 — Federal Register of Legislation
- Liquidation: a guide for creditors (INFO 45) — Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Rates checked as at 24 October 2026. Interest rates, lender policies and government schemes change frequently. Figures in this article are illustrative and were accurate at the date shown.
General advice warning: This article contains general information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not personal credit or financial advice. Consider whether it is appropriate for you and seek advice from a licensed credit representative before acting.
Any interest rate shown is an example only and is not an offer of credit. Where a rate is quoted, the applicable comparison rate is available from the relevant lender and should be considered alongside it.
Tags
Related Posts

Peer-to-Peer Lending and ASIC: The Managed Investment Schemes Behind the Platforms
Most peer-to-peer lending platforms in Australia pool investors' money, and pooled investments are managed investment schemes under the Corporations Act. That brings ASIC rules with it: an AFS lice...

Private Loan Valuations: Why the Lender's Valuer Often Comes In Lower
A private loan valuation is done for the lender, by a valuer on its panel, asking what the property would realistically fetch if the lender had to sell it within months. That is a narrower question...

Private Loan Term Sheets: Reading the Offer Line by Line
A private loan term sheet sets out the commercial terms before the loan documents are drawn: amount, term, rate, default rate, fees, prepaid interest, security, personal guarantees, conditions and...